logo for improve-your-digital-photography.com
Home
Photo Technique CSE - Photo Basics
CSE - Composition
CSE - Sharpness
CSE - Exposure
CSE - Photo Critique
Photo Examples Art & Photography
Weekly Composition
Roving @ Home
Photo Reference Digital Photo Tips
Digital Photo Q&A
Ted's Blog
DP Article Reviews
Give Ted Feedback
Yahoo! Answers
Glossary

[?] Subscribe To This Site

XML RSS
Add to Google
Add to My Yahoo!
Add to My MSN
Subscribe with Bloglines

LEFT for improve-your-digital-photography.com
 

The Roving Photographer

Photo Op 2: Meet The Ducks


In my Roving Photographer Photo Op 1 page, I tell of how a large duckling waddles through the bushes, diverting me from my real goal of photographing gardeners hard at work.

Reflexively, I took a quick, low-quality grab shot - good one for the rubbish bin, as it turned out.

But, when I turned around, I found a family of a half-dozen more ducks parading across the lawn.  This looked more promising and immensely more fun than photgraphing people, so I sat down and composed what I hoped would be a few good shots.

Ducks in profile
Nikon D300, 18-200mm VR @ 200mm, ISO 800, 1/320s, f/16
A family of ducks waddles by.

What I like about these duck photos is that I was able to get low enough to shoot profiles. The fill flash balanced well with the ambient sunlight (it was a cloudless. blue sky) and also created a nice catchlight in the duck eyes.

What I like about photographing ducks is that they aren't very shy.  They let me get fairly close while they went about their business (whatever duck business is).  As digital wildlife photography goes, this must be amongst the easiest of subjects to capture.

Ducks as comic characters
Nikon D300, 18-200mm VR @ 200mm, ISO 800, 1/400s, f/16
Comic characters.Note the catchlight in their eyes from my flash.

What I really like about ducks, that I didn't realize before this shoot, is that they are really goofy looking.  No wonder the Roving Photographer grew up with so many comic duck characters. 

So, let's look at a few more ducks.

The Roving Photgrapher Hits the Boardwalk

This may be stretching the concept of a "photo op", but let me bring in some pictures from another day, a month later, at a local lake.  Here, the conditions were more challenging, as I had to deal with different angles, distance, and lighting.

These first few pictures were taken from a boardwalk across a shallow part of the lake. 


Looking to the right of the boardwalk, I found this duck dancing in the shade. The best I can say about this duck photo is that it has great potential, but I am not pleased with the execution.
  • Poor sharpness spoils this duck photo
    Nikon D300, 18-200mm VR @ 200mm
    ISO 400, 1/50s, f/5.6
    Poor sharpness kills the impact of a good composition.
    The potential lies in thecontrast between the well-lit branch and duck, as cast against the dark water and trees.

  • The poor execution is evident in the lack of sharpness.  This comes from a combination of using a slow shutter speed (1/50 - 1/60 sec), shooting at the extreme focal length of my 18 - 200 mm lens (300 mm in 35mm equivalent), and using the widest lens aperture (f/5.6).

  • The lighting also comes off a bit too extreme.  It looks as if the branch and duck are overexposed by strobe, although no strobe was used (I had to check my EXIF data to confirm that).

  • Overall, strong reflections, punchy contrast, and the duck's pose make for a compelling composition that would benefit from more attention to image sharpness.




So, what happened?


Many zoom lenses do not perform at their sharpest when used at the maximum focal length, especially in low-light conditions.   To counteract that, I often back off slightly from full extension and stop the lens down one or two stops. Also, at an effective 300 mm focal length, any photographer motion will blur the image.  Vibration reduction in the lens is a bit help, but not a panacea.

In this case, I was a Roving Photographer asleep at the wheel and did little to take advantage of the opportunity.  I didn't back off from the maximum zoom, and I didn't use proven techniques for improving sharpness.

With a camera that shoots well at ISO 1600, I was shooting only at ISO 400. 

That deprived me of two stops of exposure value that I should have used to both speed up and stop down.

Instead of 1/50 sec @ f/5.6 -
I could have used 1/100 sec @ f/8. 

With my lens at an effective 300 mm, the increased shutter speed would have helped remove any motion blur (the lens has vibration reduction, which is the only reason I would attempt the shot at less 1/400 second). 

More important, the increased f-stop would have added depth of field to compensate for any focus error that resulted from the dim lighting conditions.

This was truly a missed opportunity for the Roving Photographer.



Better lighting conditions help The Roving Photographer.

Turning to the sunny side on the left of the boardwalk, I found myself looking nearly straight down on a duck.  With the lens fully extended to 200 mm, and 
More light helps achieve sharpness
Nikon D300, 18-200mm VR @ 200mm
ISO 400, 1/250s, f/5.6
 Working from the sunny side of the boardwalk.
the aperture wide open (f/5.6), the duck bill is in sharp focus, showing a beautiful wet sheen. 


The difference in image quality is due entirely to the light.  More light allows faster shutter speed and helps the auto-focus system do a better job of locking in.


If my exposure settings (see caption) look a little low considering the sunlight, that is because I was also using a polarizing filter to minimize - but not eliminate - reflections.  That took away about two stops of exposure value.



More Ducks - Beyond the Boardwalk

The boardwalk connects to a series of small islands that eventually lead back to the shore.   Their elevation was lower than the boardwalk, so I could sit down and get a much better view of these ducks swimming.

With the afternoon sun dropping lower in the sky, the colors are warmer.  I was still shooting with wide aperture and full 200 mm zoom. 

Duck photo with low sun
Nikon D300, 18-200mm VR @ 200mm, ISO 400, 1/400s, f/5.6
 Low afternoon sun adds warmth.

A two-headed duck?

The subject in this duck photo is on the left.  But, on the right, the foreshortening created by the long lens focal length made an interesting juxtaposition of two duck heads that appear to be on one duck.

The Roving Photographer Tries to Work a Miracle

This final duck gave me fits! 

He was excited by children throwing breadcrumbs.
Back-lit duck photo
Nikon D300, 18-200mm VR @ 200mm
ISO 400, 1/250s, f/5.6
  Backlit grab shot almost creates silhouette.
 
I was on his shadow side, with no time to move around if I wanted to capture the moment. 

He was almost jumping for joy, with his mouth open and tounge hanging out.  It was a grab shot that was too fun to pass up.

The question was: what could a roving photographer make of this poor image?



The alternatives

The challenge, here, is with the lighting.  The camera exposed well, overall, except that the subject is mostly in shadow!

After cropping the image, I experimented with exposure tweaks in software.

Exposure variation 1 - contrast
Exposure variation 2 - fill light
A slight increased in contrast brings out
some shadow detail and warmth, but
this is still largely a silhouette.
An increase in fill light brings out a
tremendous amount of detail from the
shadows and makes this a completely
different picture. 


In the end, I preferred the exposure pretty close to the original, as at the left.

Why? 

Because when I tried brightening the body, the feather colors were bland and the overall lightness made the image appear "flatter".  Ultimately, the darker body provided stronger contrast to the few warm, backlit highlights on the duck's breast.  More important, the real focal point of the picture is the goofy mouth, which works well silhouettd against the lake, but with the tounge sunlit.

Maybe this works best as a head shot.  It won't win The Roving Photogrpaher any prizes, but it should make you smile.

Ducks have tongues


Home - Improve Your Digital Photography Privacy Policy Feedback Learn about the SBI site building tools used on this site.

footer for Improve Your Digital Photography page